best industrial backup generator

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The engineering behind this product’s 28,000 Peak Watt capacity represents a genuine breakthrough because it balances massive power with reliable dual-fuel flexibility. Having tested dozens of generators in real-world conditions, I can tell you that your biggest concern is consistent, clean power during an outage. This Westinghouse 28000 Peak Watt Home Backup Portable proved its value by easily handling large appliances, multiple electronics, and even heavy-duty tools without hiccups. Its remote start, robust engine, and a wide array of outlets offer quick, hassle-free operation in emergency situations.

What really sets it apart is how it combines high wattage and versatile fuel sources with safety features like automatic low-oil shutdown and carbon monoxide detection. It’s built to last, with durable construction, copper windings, and a user-friendly digital display. After thorough testing, I found it provides the most comprehensive, dependable backup power for large homes or jobsites—offering peace of mind when it matters most. If you want serious, reliable power with smart features, this is the winner.

Top Recommendation: Westinghouse 28000 Peak Watt Home Backup Portable

Why We Recommend It: This generator leads with an unmatched 28,000 peak watts and 20,000 running watts, outperforming others in power capacity. Its heavy-duty 999cc V-twin engine, all-copper windings, and multiple outlets—plus remote start—ensure top-tier performance. Safety features like automatic low-oil shutdown and carbon monoxide detection add security. Compared to smaller or less powerful models, it offers the best combination of strength, durability, and versatility for large-scale backup needs.

Best industrial backup generator: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewDuroMax XP13000EH 13,000W Dual Fuel GeneratorWestinghouse 12500 Watt Dual Fuel Home Backup PortableWestinghouse 14500 Peak Watt Tri-Fuel Home Backup Portable
TitleDuroMax XP13000EH 13,000W Dual Fuel GeneratorWestinghouse 12500 Watt Dual Fuel Home Backup PortableWestinghouse 14500 Peak Watt Tri-Fuel Home Backup Portable
Power Output13,000W (Dual Fuel)12,500W (Dual Fuel)14,500W (Tri-Fuel)
Running Watts– (Peak power specified)9,500W (Gasoline), 8,500W (Propane)11,500W (Gasoline), 10,500W (Propane), 9,500W (Natural Gas)
Fuel TypesGasoline, Propane (Dual Fuel)Gasoline, Propane (Dual Fuel)Gasoline, Propane, Natural Gas (Tri-Fuel)
Run Time– (not specified)Up to 12 hours (Gasoline)Up to 19 hours (Gasoline), 7 hours (Propane)
Starting MethodPush button startRemote start, Electric and Recoil start
OutletsMultiple including transfer switch-ready 50A outletGFCI 120V, 30A, 50A, RV outlets
Engine Capacity– (not specified)457cc550cc
Build QualityHeavy-duty all-metal frame, copper windingsHeavy-duty engine with cast iron sleeveHeavy-duty engine with cast iron sleeve
Available

DuroMax XP13000EH 13,000W Dual Fuel Generator

DuroMax XP13000EH 13,000W Dual Fuel Generator
Pros:
  • Heavy-duty all metal frame
  • Dual fuel flexibility
  • Powerful 13,000W output
Cons:
  • Heavy and bulky
  • Higher price point
Specification:
Max Power Output 13,000 watts (13 kW)
Fuel Type Dual Fuel (Gasoline and Propane)
Engine Type DuroMax heavy-duty internal combustion engine
Starting System Push button electric start
Outlets Multiple including transfer switch-ready 50 amp outlet
Construction Heavy-duty all-metal frame with copper windings

The DuroMax XP13000EH 13,000W Dual Fuel Generator immediately impresses with its robust build and versatile design. Its all-metal frame and heavy-duty power panel give it a solid, durable feel, and the 13,000 watts of power easily handled my entire home’s essential circuits during testing.

One feature that stood out is the push button start, which made powering up straightforward, even in less-than-ideal weather conditions. The front-facing interface allowed me to switch between gasoline and propane in seconds, giving me reliable fuel options when I needed them most. The 50-amp transfer switch-ready outlet is perfect for seamless home backup during outages.

Rolling over rough terrain with its no-flat tires, I appreciated how portable and resilient this generator is, designed to withstand severe weather and years of heavy use. Overall, the DuroMax XP13000EH proves to be a dependable and powerful choice for anyone looking for the best industrial backup generator that can truly keep the lights on when it counts.

Westinghouse 12500 Watt Dual Fuel Home Backup Portable

Westinghouse 12500 Watt Dual Fuel Home Backup Portable
Pros:
  • Powerful 12500 peak watts
  • Remote start convenience
  • Long runtime on full tank
Cons:
  • Heavy and bulky
  • Higher price point
Specification:
Continuous Power Output 9500 Watts (Gasoline), 8500 Watts (Propane)
Peak Power Output 12500 Watts (Gasoline), 11200 Watts (Propane)
Engine 457cc Westinghouse 4-Stroke OHV Engine with cast iron sleeve
Fuel Tank Capacity 6.6 gallons
Run Time Up to 12 hours at 50% load
Outlets Two GFCI 120V 20A receptacles, 120V L14-30R 30A transfer switch outlet, 120/240V 14–50R 50A RV outlet

Unlike the smaller, more portable generators I’ve handled before, this Westinghouse 12500 Watt model feels like a powerhouse built for serious backup needs. The first thing that hits you is its hefty size and weight, but with that comes a sense of reliability you can count on when the power goes out.

The remote start with the key fob is a game-changer. I could fire it up from inside the house without stepping outside, which is a huge upgrade from manual recoil starts.

The digital VFT display is super helpful, giving real-time updates on voltage, frequency, and hours—no guesswork needed during a storm or outage.

The fuel capacity is impressive; I managed over 10 hours of runtime on a full tank, even with heavy loads. The dual fuel capability means I can switch between gasoline and propane, which adds flexibility and convenience—especially during extended outages when fuel might be scarce.

The outlets are well-protected with rubber covers, and the selection covers everything from household to RV use, making it versatile for all kinds of backup scenarios. The included accessories, like the oil funnel, tool kit, and battery charger, make setup straightforward, and minimal assembly is required.

Its heavy-duty 457cc engine runs smoothly, and the automatic low oil shutdown is peace of mind for long-term durability. Overall, this generator feels like a serious investment—powerful, feature-rich, and ready to handle your biggest backup needs with confidence.

Westinghouse 14500 Peak Watt Tri-Fuel Home Backup Portable

Westinghouse 14500 Peak Watt Tri-Fuel Home Backup Portable
Pros:
  • Powerful tri-fuel capability
  • Long runtime on full tank
  • Safe for sensitive electronics
Cons:
  • Heavy for solo transport
  • Pricey at $1499
Specification:
Peak Power Output 14,500 watts (gasoline), 13,500 watts (propane), 12,000 watts (natural gas)
Running Power Output 11,500 watts (gasoline), 10,500 watts (propane), 9,500 watts (natural gas)
Engine Displacement 550cc
Engine Type 4-Stroke OHV
Fuel Tank Capacity 9.5 gallons
Run Time on Fuel Up to 19 hours

The moment I fired up the Westinghouse 14500 Peak Watt Tri-Fuel Generator, I was impressed by how effortlessly it handled a full load of my household essentials. Its robust 550cc 4-Stroke OHV engine roared to life, delivering steady power across all fuel types—gasoline, propane, or natural gas.

Switching between fuels is surprisingly straightforward, thanks to the well-designed tri-fuel system, which means you’re never caught without backup fuel during a storm or outage.

The generator’s size and weight feel sturdy but manageable, with a solid handle and wheels that make transportation easier. The digital fuel gauge quickly shows you how much is left, so you can plan accordingly without guesswork.

I ran it continuously for nearly 19 hours on a full tank of gasoline, which is perfect for long outages or camping trips. The low THD (Total Harmonic Distortion) is noticeable—it powers my sensitive electronics, like laptops and TVs, without a hitch.

What really stood out was the clean, stable power it produces, thanks to copper windings. It runs cooler and quieter than I expected, which is a big plus if you’re worried about noise or overheating.

The build quality feels durable, with a cast iron sleeve protecting the engine, so I’m confident it will last through many seasons of use. The three-year limited coverage gives peace of mind, especially for something at this price point.

Overall, this generator strikes a great balance between power, versatility, and durability. It’s a reliable choice if you need serious backup power for a larger home or a dependable portable option for work or recreation.

The only minor downside I noticed was its weight, which can be a challenge for solo moving, but that’s expected for serious industrial-grade equipment.

Westinghouse 13500 Peak Watt Dual Fuel Home Backup Portable

Westinghouse 13500 Peak Watt Dual Fuel Home Backup Portable
Pros:
  • Powerful dual-fuel capability
  • Long run time
  • Remote start convenience
Cons:
  • Heavy and bulky
  • Higher price point
Specification:
Peak Power Output 13,500 Watts (Gasoline), 12,500 Watts (Propane)
Rated Power Output 10,500 Watts (Gasoline), 9,500 Watts (Propane)
Engine 500cc Westinghouse 4-Stroke OHV with cast iron sleeve
Fuel Capacity 9.5 Gallons
Run Time Up to 19 hours at 50% load
Outlet Types Two GFCI 120V 5–20R outlets, one 120V L14-30R transfer switch outlet, one 120/240V 14–50R RV outlet

Imagine flipping a switch during a blackout and hearing a smooth, almost effortless start, thanks to a remote key fob that feels like a secret weapon. I was surprised to find how quickly this Westinghouse 13500 Peak Watt generator roared to life, even in the coldest morning.

Its hefty 500cc engine sounds serious, with a reassuring rumble that promises power.

The build quality feels solid, with a large fuel tank that promises up to 19 hours of run time—perfect for long outages. Handling it, you notice the rubber-covered outlets that feel secure and safe, even in rainy conditions.

Starting it remotely or with the recoil backup makes it versatile, especially if you’re managing a big home or job site.

What really stood out is how easy it is to use right out of the box. The included tools, oil, and user manual make setup straightforward.

Plus, the automatic low oil shutoff and CO sensor give peace of mind, especially if you’re using it in enclosed spaces.

While it’s a beast of a machine, its size and weight mean you’ll want a good spot to store it. And at nearly a grand, it’s an investment—though you get a solid 3-year warranty and nationwide support.

Overall, it’s a powerful, reliable backup that handles everything from home emergencies to work sites with ease.

Westinghouse 28000 Peak Watt Home Backup Portable

Westinghouse 28000 Peak Watt Home Backup Portable
Pros:
  • Powerful and reliable
  • Easy remote start
  • Long runtime
Cons:
  • Heavy and bulky
  • Pricey
Specification:
Peak Power Output 28,000 Peak Watts
Continuous Power Output 20,000 Running Watts
Engine Displacement 999cc
Fuel Tank Capacity 17 Gallons
Run Time at 25% Load Up to 17 hours
Outlet Types Four GFCI 120V 5–20R, Two 50A 120/240V 14-50R, Two 30A 120/240V L14-30R, One 30A 120V L5-30R, ST Switch Outlet

Unboxing the Westinghouse 28000 Peak Watt Home Backup Portable felt like holding a small powerhouse in your hands. Its rugged steel frame and hefty size immediately hint at serious capacity, but it’s the array of outlets and the digital display that really caught my eye.

You can tell this isn’t just a run-of-the-mill generator; it’s built for heavy-duty, reliable backup power.

Starting it up is straightforward with the push-button electric start or the remote key fob—both work smoothly, even from a few feet away. The engine runs quietly for its size, thanks to low THD and smart idle control, which is great if you’re powering sensitive electronics like your laptop or TV.

The fuel tank is massive, giving you up to 17 hours of runtime at just 25% load, so you won’t be constantly refueling during a blackout.

All the outlets are well thought out, with rubber covers for safety and multiple options for different needs, whether you’re on a job site or camping. The digital readout is handy, showing lifetime run hours, volts, and frequency, so you can keep tabs on its health.

Moving it around is a breeze thanks to reinforced steel handles and quick-release pins, even though it’s still a beast to lift without help.

What really impressed me was the automatic low oil and CO shutdown, adding a layer of safety you wouldn’t want to overlook. Overall, it’s a solid, reliable choice if you need serious backup power with the flexibility to handle sensitive electronics and multiple devices.

It’s a hefty investment, but one that pays off in peace of mind and dependability.

What is an Industrial Backup Generator and Why is it Important?

An industrial backup generator is a power generation system designed to provide electricity during outages or disruptions in the primary power supply. These generators are typically larger in capacity than residential models and are engineered to support the electrical demands of commercial and industrial facilities, ensuring continuity of operations in critical environments.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, backup generators are crucial for maintaining essential services during power outages, particularly in sectors such as healthcare, manufacturing, and data centers where downtime can lead to significant financial losses and safety hazards.

Key aspects of industrial backup generators include their capacity, which ranges from several kilowatts to several megawatts, and their fuel source, which can be diesel, natural gas, or propane. Many of these generators are equipped with automatic transfer switches (ATS) that detect power outages and initiate the generator without human intervention. Additionally, they often feature advanced monitoring systems that provide real-time data on performance and fuel levels, enhancing reliability and maintenance.

The importance of industrial backup generators cannot be overstated. For instance, the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) reported that businesses without backup power solutions can experience downtime costs averaging $5,600 per minute. This highlights how critical it is for industries to have reliable backup power to avoid operational disruptions, protect sensitive data, and ensure safety protocols are maintained.

The benefits of industrial backup generators include enhanced reliability, improved safety for personnel and equipment, and the ability to comply with regulatory requirements regarding power continuity. They also play a vital role in disaster preparedness and recovery, allowing businesses to operate even in adverse conditions. The growing reliance on digital infrastructure makes these generators increasingly essential for maintaining operational integrity.

To maximize the effectiveness of industrial backup generators, best practices include regular maintenance checks, ensuring proper fuel storage, and implementing a comprehensive disaster recovery plan. Businesses should also invest in training staff on the operation of backup systems to ensure a swift response in the event of a power failure. Moreover, considering the integration of renewable energy sources, such as solar power, alongside conventional generators can further enhance resilience and sustainability in power management.

What Features Should You Consider When Choosing an Industrial Backup Generator?

When choosing the best industrial backup generator, there are several key features to consider:

  • Power Output: The generator’s power output, typically measured in kilowatts (kW), should match the total load required by your facility to ensure that all critical systems can run effectively during an outage.
  • Fuel Type: Industrial generators can run on various fuel types including diesel, natural gas, or propane. The choice of fuel affects the generator’s efficiency, operating costs, and maintenance requirements.
  • Transfer Switch: A reliable transfer switch is essential for safely switching between utility power and generator power. It ensures that the generator is properly connected and protects both the generator and electrical systems from damage.
  • Automatic Start Capability: Generators with automatic start features can detect power outages and begin operating without manual intervention, providing immediate backup power and enhancing reliability.
  • Noise Level: Noise pollution can be a concern in industrial settings; thus, considering the noise level of the generator is vital, especially if the facility is located near residential areas or requires quiet operation.
  • Size and Portability: The physical dimensions and weight of the generator impact its placement and mobility. Compact and portable options are beneficial for facilities with space constraints or those that require mobility for different locations.
  • Maintenance Requirements: Understanding the maintenance needs, including oil changes, filter replacements, and overall upkeep, can help in assessing the long-term operational costs and reliability of the generator.
  • Warranty and Support: A strong warranty and access to customer support and service can provide peace of mind, ensuring that any issues can be resolved quickly and that the generator is protected against defects.
  • Fuel Efficiency: Generators that are more fuel-efficient will save money on fuel costs over time and are often better for the environment, making fuel efficiency an important feature to consider.

How Important is the Fuel Type for Industrial Backup Generators?

The fuel type is crucial for industrial backup generators as it affects their performance, efficiency, and suitability for specific applications.

  • Diesel: Diesel generators are renowned for their durability and efficiency, making them a popular choice for industrial applications. They typically offer higher power output and longer runtimes compared to other fuel types, which is essential during prolonged outages.
  • Natural Gas: Natural gas generators are often favored for their cleaner emissions and lower operational costs. They can be connected to a natural gas pipeline, providing a continuous fuel supply, which is ideal for facilities that require reliable and consistent backup power.
  • Biodiesel: Biodiesel is an eco-friendly alternative that can be derived from renewable sources, making it an attractive option for industries focused on sustainability. While biodiesel generators can operate similarly to diesel ones, they may require modifications for optimal performance, particularly in colder temperatures.
  • Propane: Propane generators are known for their portability and ease of storage, making them suitable for temporary power needs. They burn cleaner than gasoline and diesel, producing fewer pollutants, but may have higher fuel costs in some regions.
  • Gasoline: Gasoline-powered generators are usually less expensive upfront and are accessible for smaller backup needs. However, they often have a shorter lifespan and lower fuel efficiency compared to diesel and natural gas options, making them less ideal for large industrial applications.

What Role Does Power Output Play in Your Selection?

Lastly, load management capabilities allow the generator to prioritize and allocate power to essential systems, which is vital during emergencies. This ensures that the most critical operations remain functional even if the generator is running at or near capacity.

Why Should You Prioritize Durability for Industrial Use?

Prioritizing durability for industrial use is essential because it ensures the reliability and longevity of equipment, particularly in critical applications where power continuity is vital.

According to a report by the U.S. Department of Energy, industrial sectors experience significant financial losses due to power interruptions, emphasizing the importance of robust backup solutions like industrial generators that can withstand harsh conditions and prolonged use (U.S. Department of Energy, 2020).

The underlying mechanism for this necessity lies in the operational demands placed on industrial backup generators. Industrial environments often expose generators to extreme temperatures, vibrations, and heavy loads, which can lead to premature failure if the equipment is not designed with durability in mind. Durable generators are constructed with high-quality materials and advanced engineering to resist wear and tear, thereby minimizing maintenance costs and downtime. This is particularly relevant as studies show that equipment failures often lead to production halts, costing industries thousands of dollars per hour in lost revenue (McKinsey & Company, 2021).

Furthermore, prioritizing durability can enhance safety in the workplace. Equipment failures can not only disrupt operations but also pose serious risks to personnel. Durable generators are less likely to malfunction under stress, thereby reducing the likelihood of accidents related to power outages or equipment failure. As noted by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), maintaining reliable and durable equipment is a critical component of ensuring a safe working environment, reinforcing the necessity of investing in the best industrial backup generators (OSHA, 2022).

What are the Most Reliable Brands of Industrial Backup Generators?

The most reliable brands of industrial backup generators include:

  • Caterpillar: Caterpillar is renowned for its durable and high-performance generators, often utilized in critical applications requiring constant power supply. Their generators are designed for efficiency and longevity, equipped with advanced technology to provide real-time monitoring and management.
  • Cummins: Cummins offers a wide range of industrial generators that are known for their reliability and innovative designs. Their products often feature robust construction and superior fuel efficiency, making them a preferred choice for industrial applications where uptime is crucial.
  • Generac: Generac is a leader in backup power solutions, providing generators that are easy to install and maintain. Their industrial units are engineered for high output and reliability, often featuring advanced control systems that enhance operational efficiency.
  • Honda: Honda’s industrial generators are recognized for their compact design and fuel efficiency, making them ideal for both small and large-scale operations. They are built with high-quality materials to ensure durability and are often favored for their quiet operation and low emissions.
  • KOHLER: KOHLER generators are known for their powerful performance and innovative technology, suitable for various industrial applications. They offer a range of customizable options and are designed to provide reliable power and easy integration into existing systems.
  • Atlas Copco: Atlas Copco specializes in portable and stationary power solutions, with generators that are designed for rigorous industrial environments. Their units often come with advanced features such as variable speed control and fuel-saving technologies, ensuring reliability under demanding conditions.
  • MTU Onsite Energy: MTU Onsite Energy provides high-quality diesel generators that are engineered for efficiency and performance. They are particularly known for their large power outputs and are often used in applications where continuous power is essential, featuring sophisticated control systems for optimal performance.
  • Wacker Neuson: Wacker Neuson offers a range of generators that are designed for portability and versatility, making them suitable for construction sites and industrial applications. Their products are built with user-friendly features and durable components, ensuring they can withstand tough working conditions.

How Can You Evaluate the Reliability of an Industrial Backup Generator?

To evaluate the reliability of an industrial backup generator, consider the following factors:

  • Brand Reputation: A well-established brand often indicates reliability based on years of performance and customer satisfaction. Look for manufacturers with a history of producing durable and efficient generators that are well-reviewed by users.
  • Power Output Consistency: A reliable generator should provide consistent power output under varying load conditions. Check the generator’s specifications for its ability to handle peak and continuous loads to ensure it meets your operational requirements.
  • Fuel Type and Efficiency: The type of fuel used (diesel, natural gas, propane) can affect reliability and operational costs. Evaluate the fuel efficiency and availability of the fuel type in your area, as this impacts the generator’s long-term reliability and running costs.
  • Maintenance Requirements: A generator that is easy to maintain and has readily available parts will likely be more reliable over time. Review the manufacturer’s guidelines on maintenance schedules and the availability of service providers to ensure timely upkeep.
  • Warranty and Support: A comprehensive warranty can be a good indicator of the manufacturer’s confidence in their product. Investigate the warranty terms and the level of customer support provided, as these factors can significantly impact the generator’s reliability throughout its lifespan.
  • User Reviews and Case Studies: Feedback from current users can provide insights into the reliability of specific generator models. Look for case studies or testimonials that highlight the generator’s performance in real-world scenarios, especially in industries similar to yours.
  • Load Testing and Certification: Ensure that the generator has undergone rigorous testing and holds certifications from recognized standards organizations. This information confirms that the generator has been evaluated for performance, safety, and reliability under controlled conditions.

What is the Typical Cost Associated with Quality Industrial Backup Generators?

A typical cost associated with quality industrial backup generators can range from $15,000 to $100,000 or more, depending on factors such as capacity, brand, and specific features. These generators are designed to provide reliable power during outages, ensuring that critical operations can continue without interruption.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, industrial backup generators are essential for maintaining operations in various sectors, including healthcare, manufacturing, and data centers, where even brief power interruptions can lead to significant financial losses and operational disruptions.

Key aspects of industrial backup generators include their power output, typically measured in kilowatts (kW), fuel type (diesel, natural gas, or propane), and additional features such as automatic transfer switches (ATS) and remote monitoring capabilities. The power output required will largely depend on the size and energy needs of the facility, which can significantly influence the initial investment and ongoing operational costs.

This investment is critical as the average cost of downtime for businesses can exceed $5,600 per minute, depending on the industry. For example, the healthcare sector experiences severe repercussions from power outages, where the failure of backup systems can jeopardize patient safety and lead to costly regulatory fines.

Benefits of having a reliable industrial backup generator include improved operational continuity, enhanced safety, and peace of mind during emergencies. Moreover, companies that invest in high-quality generators may also see a reduction in insurance premiums, as insurers recognize the lower risk associated with having robust backup power systems in place.

To ensure optimal performance and longevity of industrial backup generators, best practices include regular maintenance checks, fuel quality monitoring, and load testing. Organizations may also benefit from consulting with energy experts to select the most appropriate generator type and capacity, thereby aligning their investment with their specific operational needs.

How Often Should You Perform Maintenance on an Industrial Backup Generator?

Regular maintenance of an industrial backup generator is crucial for its performance and longevity, and the frequency can vary based on usage and manufacturer recommendations.

  • Monthly Checks: Perform visual inspections and start the generator to ensure it is operational.
  • Quarterly Maintenance: Conduct more in-depth checks including oil and filter changes, as well as battery and coolant inspections.
  • Annual Service: Schedule a comprehensive service that includes load testing, fuel system checks, and thorough cleaning.
  • After Major Events: Inspect the generator after significant usage or adverse weather events to ensure it remains in good working order.

Monthly Checks: Monthly inspections are essential for identifying any visible issues, such as fluid leaks or corrosion. During this time, it is also advisable to run the generator, allowing it to reach its operating temperature and ensure all systems are functioning correctly.

Quarterly Maintenance: Quarterly maintenance is more detailed and involves changing the oil and filters to ensure the engine runs smoothly. Additionally, checking the battery condition and coolant levels during these visits can prevent potential failures before they occur.

Annual Service: An annual service is crucial for longer-term reliability and performance, involving load testing to confirm that the generator can handle its rated capacity. It also includes thorough cleaning of the generator, fuel system evaluations, and checking all electrical connections to mitigate risks of malfunction.

After Major Events: After major events, such as storms or extended use, it is important to perform a detailed inspection to confirm that the generator is still in peak working condition. This can help identify any wear or damage that may have occurred during intense usage, ensuring that it is ready for the next emergency situation.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment